Diet Protocol

Facebook iconTwitter iconGoogle icon

A lot came up today about diet protocol. And, I realize this is a heated subject because people have a lot of strong feelings about diet, including me of course. However, if you are trying to do this protocol then it is probably very good to try and eat within the guidelines of what we are suggesting you do. If you want to be stricter that's great-or, is it? Sometimes it isn't actually.

I had an interesting conversation today with someone actually who feels better with some small amount of carbs in. Her burning was actually worse without. Why would this be? Because carbs are not all bad- some carbs allow you the fuel you need to get from meal to meal.

People have critized this treatment over the years for allowing carbs in. People also criticize us for allowing gluten. However, our reasons are not baseless. This treatment is based on experience and observation.

With zero carbs the body typically will burn too "hot" and carbs are needed to balance things out. Also, without those carbs, people can become too fatigued, and can even experience palpitations. I have had a couple people over the years end up in the ER as a consequence of not eating them. That said-I have also seen a few people do super well excluding them. I find most people fall in the middle, which is why I recommend keep in carbs and limiting to 25%. Also, if you do want to exclude them-the dinner meal is the one to choose because you don't need the carbs at night before winding down and going to bed,w hereas you do need the energy in the morning and mid day.

Last thing-I have people who believe that this is a gluten problem and that they need to be gluten free. Are there people who need to eat gluten free? Certainly. Is this condition largely linked to gluten-only in that we eat way too much of it, BUT, that is very different than the implication that one must exclude it completely. This diet is one of cutting so far so back that the diet is allows the supplements to work and do their job. As the inflammation goes down the food can go up.

High amounts of carbs and gluten are never a good idea, but most people can have small to even moderate amounts without problem. One needs to look at the big picture and the overall diet. And it is very much the process that a person is going through to clean and balance their systems that creates health.

Lastly, in order to create encouragement to others, try not to say that your way is the only way. I am not saying that anyone is doing that, but, I find that sometimes over the years I get emails from people that feel judged and then want to retreat from speaking on line with everyone. This is a shame because everyone should get help and encouragement.

So if there is a conversation where people disagree or are not sure, feel free to ask me what I think so I can help sort it out. Hopefully this will help people's participation. 

Another important thing about carbs-I have found over the years that some people can eat one carb while that carb is really problematic for another. And, that is non-gluten carbs. So, it is important to identify those problems to help keep the pain down. Also one might even want to eat white rice (AKA the unhealthy version of rice) in order to have something to eat if they cannot eat brown rice temporarily until their body is strong enough to be able to handle the brown rice. Why? Because the brown rice is more abrasive to the gut than the white that is stripped of all of its fibrous hull.

I know, this is a long text, and I am beginning to ramble a little. My point is this--there are a LOT of issues-many more than have been mentioned here to diet and carbs. It is so incredible everyone is helping everyone. Try to keep it positive and helpful and please remember to respect we all have our differences as much as we have our similarities.

Dr.M & B

 

Comments

deir's picture
deir

What about "cumulative" effect? If you eat a certain food pretty much every day and find that it is not affecting your number of good or bad days can you assume it is ok? Meaning you eat spelt Mon, Tues and Wed and only Tues is bad- can you assume the food is not the culprit ? Or is it possible that the food is bothering you over time despite having good days on it? In this case, how do you know it isn't the herbs helping vs taking out foods? Not sure if this makes sense!! Thanks for taking the time for this!

drbrizman's picture
drbrizman

Cumulatively carbs will effect you if you are consistently over eating them. So, think of carbs like gasoline in a car-it uses what it needs to get from place to place. But, in the body, if you eat too much and dont burn it off, it turns to sugar and then feeds overgrowth. Also, the big trick with IC is the kind of carb and making sure it is not abrasive to your insides because this will literally cause more leakage from the small intestine into the lymph.

deir's picture
deir

Thanks! This really helps me understand better!

cprince's picture
cprince

Is a reaction to carbs always a negative one like nausea, bloating, reflux, obvious undigested grains, or ok to keep trying a small portion with one meal and will eventually get body strong enough to not have painful or unpleasant reaction? Or always a sign, still too early feeding the inflammation or imbalance and keep plugging along trying back in a few weeks? I keep trying as I feel like I need a good swift kick in the pants to get going, but never feel energized just yuck after eating. Thanks!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

drbrizman's picture
drbrizman

IT can be nausea and bloating, or it can be severe fatigue after a meal-that is common. It can be  host of things but bloating, gas and fatigue are the most common. If you eat just a tiny bit, typically, this will re-energize you and not cause those problems. But, as I said, everyone IS different, and I have seen some people really need to withohold them completely until they can get further ahead and then introduce them. But, the way you know if that is the case is if you feel so much more energy by taking them out. It is a really clear reaction. Most people do not feel that way though.

cprince's picture
cprince

That is helpful, thank you! I try to get carbs from other things, like avocado and beans, to try to keep my fuel up, hopefully an ok way to swap things out? I know I would crash and burn other wise! Thanks again!

ktgicama's picture
ktgicama

I really appreciate your explaining this. I've been wondering this myself, so it's helpful to know your reasonings. I tried omitting carbs at dinner recently, and I was just so hungry when I went to bed that I decided my body must need them. Of course, everyone is different.

headley.patty@gmail.com's picture
headley.patty@g...

Thank you so much for this post.  I knew I had an overage of yeast for years before my I realized I had IC.  I tried so hard to follow their carb-free diet but never adapted to it and never felt good like they said I would.  I was so thankful when I came to your website that I could incorporate some healthy carbs because I definitely do feel better with some.  I know I must be careful though because when I feel really good I tend to want to overdo those carbs which I know can be problematic.  I was confused though that all anti-candida diets say no carbs...so I really appreciate your explanation.  It definitely helps us stay on the right track when we have a little better understanding.  Thanks again.